
Arlo Midtown
Best for social, budget-conscious travelers who want a central Midtown base with lively bars, flexible event spaces and a rooftop.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Arlo Midtown is a 4-star, approachable Midtown Manhattan hotel with compact modern rooms, active dining outlets and a seasonal rooftop — good for social travelers, families and business visitors. Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York is a design-forward five-star luxury property near MoMA and Fifth Avenue — read this if you want classic luxury, a full-service spa and a quieter, more formal downtown experience.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for social, budget-conscious travelers who want a central Midtown base with lively bars, flexible event spaces and a rooftop.

Best for travelers seeking five-star luxury, a dedicated full-service spa, and a landmark address steps from MoMA and Fifth Avenue.
When Arlo Midtown wins: choose Arlo if you want a more casual, social Midtown stay with multiple dining outlets, a seasonal rooftop bar, 24/7 fitness access and larger meeting/event capacity at a 4-star price point.
When Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York wins: pick Baccarat for a quieter, five-star luxury experience — fewer rooms, a full-service spa, an indoor pool and French dining in a location that puts museum and Fifth Avenue shopping within easy walking distance.
Bottom line: both are stylish Manhattan hotels; Arlo Midtown leans approachable and social and works well for families, groups and business events, while Baccarat is the choice for travelers who prioritize high-end service, spa amenities and a classic luxury address.
| Category | Arlo Midtown | Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Casual, social, modern 4-star with rooftop programming | Design-forward, five-star luxury and formal service |
| Location | Garment District / West 38th St — near Times Square, Penn Station, Javits | 28 West 53rd St — steps from MoMA, close to Fifth Avenue and Rockefeller Center |
| Size (rooms) | 489 rooms | 114 guestrooms |
| Family / age policy | All ages welcome; check-in minimum 21 | All ages welcome (adults-only: false) — check-in minimum not published |
| Pools | No swimming pool on-site | Indoor pool (1) |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple outlets: Altair (main), The Bar Room at Altair, Café at Altair, seasonal ART Midtown rooftop | Grand Salon (French restaurant) and bar/lounge; room service during limited hours |
| Spa & wellness | 24-hour fitness and wellness studio; wellness partnerships for treatments (no named full-service spa) | Full-service spa with treatments, sauna and steam facilities |
| Known for | Rooftop bar, event/meeting capacity, Urban Fee perks (Citi Bike, Alo Moves, in-room WiFi) | Luxury Baccarat brand, proximity to MoMA/Fifth Avenue, crystal-inspired design and formal French dining |
| Accessibility | Accessible path to entrance, accessible fitness center and public washroom; braille/raised signage | Wheelchair accessible (may have limitations); assistive listening devices available; braille/raised signage noted |
| Parking & transport | No on-site parking; partner garage with validation; near major subway hubs and Penn Station | Covered parking and limo/town car service available; airport shuttle (surcharge) offered |
Arlo Midtown sits on West 38th Street in the Garment District, midway between Times Square and Hudson Yards.
Good for travelers who want to be in the thick of Midtown activity and near convention/commuter hubs.
Baccarat Hotel is on West 53rd Street, steps from the Museum of Modern Art and Fifth Avenue shopping.
Choose Baccarat for a more museum- and shopping-focused Midtown base with a calmer immediate street feel.
Arlo Midtown offers a large inventory of compact, modern rooms and several suite options.
Expect efficient, modern rooms with practical amenities and an urban-fee structure.
Baccarat's guestrooms are fewer in number and arranged to reflect a five-star design sensibility.
Baccarat focuses on high-end finishes, full-suite options and personalized service in fewer, larger rooms.
Arlo Midtown emphasizes all-day dining and social bars across several on-site venues.
Better if you want varied on-site dining and casual nightlife without leaving the hotel.
Baccarat centers food and drink around a more formal French dining experience.
Ideal for travelers who prefer a single, refined dining program and a quieter restaurant ambiance.
Arlo Midtown does not have a pool; its signature amenity is rooftop programming and a 24-hour fitness studio.
Pick Arlo for rooftop social life and fitness, not swimming or a resort pool experience.
Baccarat offers a full-service spa and an indoor pool as core luxury amenities.
Choose Baccarat if an on-site pool and a dedicated spa are priorities.
Arlo focuses on accessible wellness and lively nightlife programming.
Good balance of everyday fitness options plus social nightlife and seasonal rooftop events.
Baccarat’s nightlife is low-key and tied to its luxury dining and bar spaces; wellness centers on the spa.
Better for guests who want calm, polished evenings and professional spa services.

Arlo Midtown — seasonal ART Midtown rooftop and multiple bars make it a social choice (when open).

Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York — full-service spa and indoor pool on-site.

Arlo Midtown — closer to Javits Center, Penn Station and offers larger flexible meeting/event spaces.

Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York — luxury service and an address steps from MoMA and Fifth Avenue.
Both welcome families, but Arlo Midtown emphasizes family-friendly programming and larger room inventory; Baccarat is a quieter five-star option that also accepts children.
Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York has an indoor pool; Arlo Midtown does not have a swimming pool.
Baccarat is closer to MoMA and Fifth Avenue shopping; Arlo is more central to Times Square, Javits Center and Penn Station.
Only Baccarat lists a full-service spa; Arlo Midtown provides a 24-hour fitness and wellness studio and partners for in-room or contracted treatments.
Explore how Arlo Midtown stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·