
Arlo Midtown
Best for travelers who want an affordable, social Midtown base with easy access to Times Square, convention sites and rooftop nightlife.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Arlo Midtown is a lively, compact 4-star hotel in the Garment District with rooftop drinks and social spaces for travelers who want energetic, well-located accommodations. Park Hyatt New York is a modern five-star luxury hotel near Central Park and Midtown cultural venues for guests seeking full-service spa, larger rooms and quieter luxury.
Updated · about 1.6 km apart

Best for travelers who want an affordable, social Midtown base with easy access to Times Square, convention sites and rooftop nightlife.

Best for travelers who want modern five-star rooms, an on-site spa and indoor pool steps from Carnegie Hall and Central Park.
When Arlo Midtown wins: choose Arlo if you want a more casual, social Midtown stay — compact rooms, all-day dining, a seasonal rooftop bar and lower friction for group and convention travel near Javits, Penn Station and Times Square.
When Park Hyatt New York wins: pick Park Hyatt for quieter, larger rooms or suites, full-service spa treatments, an indoor pool and a more traditionally luxurious Midtown experience very close to Central Park and Carnegie Hall.
Bottom line: Arlo Midtown is the practical, social choice for younger groups, business travelers and convention-goers; Park Hyatt New York is the pick for travelers who prefer five-star service, larger accommodations and on-site wellness amenities.
| Category | Arlo Midtown | Park Hyatt New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Lively, social, compact urban hotel with rooftop bar and coworking areas. | Modern five-star luxury hotel; quiet, upscale and service-focused. |
| Location | Garment District / West 38th St — close to Javits, Penn Station, Times Square. | 153 West 57th Street — steps from Carnegie Hall and a short walk to Central Park. |
| Size (rooms) | 489 rooms | 210 rooms |
| Audience / ages | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 21. | All ages welcome (not adults-only). |
| Pools | No swimming pool (fitness studio instead). | Indoor pool and hot tub on site. |
| Restaurants & bars | Altair (signature), The Bar Room at Altair, Café at Altair, seasonal rooftop ART Midtown. | The Living Room (restaurant/bar), 24-hour room service; one bar/lounge listed. |
| Spa & wellness | 24-hour fitness and wellness studio, rooftop yoga and wellness partnerships (no standalone spa). | Full-service spa with treatments, plus steam room and fitness facilities. |
| Known for | Social spaces, rooftop events, convention proximity and value-conscious urban stays. | Five-star service, proximity to Central Park/Carnegie Hall, larger suites and wellness facilities. |
| Key fees / extras | Mandatory nightly Urban Fee (USD 37 + tax) covering Wi‑Fi, Citi Bike passes, bottled water and other perks. | Optional fees published for breakfast, self-parking/valet and pet stays (amounts listed by property). |
| Check-in time | 3:00 PM (early check-in for fee available). | 4:00 PM (supplier listing). |
Arlo Midtown sits on West 38th Street in the Garment District, close to Penn Station, Javits and Times Square.
Choose Arlo for high-energy Midtown access and short walks to convention and transport hubs.
Park Hyatt New York is on West 57th Street, within steps of Carnegie Hall and a short walk to Central Park.
Pick Park Hyatt for an upscale Midtown base near Central Park and cultural attractions.
Arlo Midtown packages compact, modern rooms and a handful of suite options with efficient layouts.
Arlo’s rooms are designed for short stays and social travelers who plan to spend time out in the city.
Park Hyatt offers larger rooms and many suite configurations, aimed at five-star comfort.
Park Hyatt suits guests who prioritize room size, residential-style suites and in-room comfort.
Arlo Midtown emphasizes social dining and a seasonal rooftop bar alongside a cafe and cocktail bar.
Arlo’s food-and-drink lineup leans social and casual with a rooftop option in season.
Park Hyatt offers a single on-site restaurant and 24-hour room service as part of a quieter, upscale food experience.
Park Hyatt is better if you want quieter, more formal dining and in-room service options.
Arlo Midtown does not have a pool but emphasizes a 24-hour fitness and wellness studio and rooftop programming.
Arlo focuses on fitness and rooftop social programming rather than poolside lounging.
Park Hyatt New York provides a full-service spa and an indoor pool as part of its wellness offering.
Park Hyatt is the clear choice if an on-site pool and a staffed spa are important to you.
Arlo Midtown programs rooftop yoga and on-demand fitness alongside a lively bar scene.
Arlo blends wellness programming with active nightlife and social spaces.
Park Hyatt’s wellness focus is spa-led and quieter, with limited nightlife on site.
Park Hyatt favors a quieter, wellness-first environment over social nightlife.

Arlo Midtown: close to Javits Center, Penn Station and Port Authority, with convention-friendly meeting spaces.

Park Hyatt New York: full-service spa, indoor pool, hot tub and steam room.

Arlo Midtown: seasonal ART Midtown rooftop bar and regular rooftop programming (when open).

Park Hyatt New York: many one-bedroom and specialty suites for travelers who want separate living space.
Both welcome children of all ages, but Arlo Midtown positions itself as family-friendly and is close to Midtown attractions; Park Hyatt offers larger rooms/suites that may suit families wanting more space.
Arlo Midtown does not have a pool. Park Hyatt New York has an indoor pool, hot tub and steam room.
Arlo Midtown adds a mandatory Urban Fee (USD 37 + tax per night) that includes Wi‑Fi and other perks. Park Hyatt lists optional fees for breakfast, parking and pets.
Park Hyatt New York is a short walk from Central Park; Arlo Midtown is farther south and requires a subway ride or longer walk to reach the park.
Explore how Arlo Midtown stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·