Arlo Midtown
Best for younger travelers, event planners and groups who want modern design, flexible meeting spaces and a seasonal rooftop bar.
Hotel comparison guide
Arlo Midtown vs Four Seasons Hotel New York
Arlo Midtown is a design-forward, event-friendly 4-star hotel in the Garment District with compact modern rooms and a seasonal rooftop; this guide is for travelers who want lively, flexible Midtown lodging and rooftop event space. Four Seasons Hotel New York is a high-profile five-star Midtown address with polished service and larger, traditionally luxurious guestrooms; read on if you want a classic luxury stay and Central Park–adjacent prestige.
Updated · about 3.2 km apart
Four Seasons Hotel New York
Best for guests seeking classic five-star service, larger suites and a prestigious Midtown address near Central Park and Fifth Avenue.
Quick Verdict: Arlo Midtown vs Four Seasons Hotel New York
When Arlo Midtown wins: choose Arlo Midtown if you want a younger, design-led hotel with strong event and rooftop options, straightforward included Wi‑Fi via the Urban Fee, and a location that’s especially convenient for Javits Center, Penn Station and the theater district.
When Four Seasons Hotel New York wins: choose Four Seasons if you want a formal five‑star experience, individually decorated larger rooms and suites, and a reputation and service level that suits upscale business travel or special-occasion stays near Central Park and Fifth Avenue.
Bottom line: Arlo Midtown is the practical, younger-leaning Midtown pick with flexible event spaces and a seasonal rooftop; Four Seasons Hotel New York is the traditional luxury choice for guests prioritizing five-star polish and larger suite options.
Arlo Midtown vs Four Seasons Hotel New York – At a Glance
| Category | Arlo Midtown | Four Seasons Hotel New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Young, design-forward, event-friendly | Classic five-star luxury, polished service |
| Location (Midtown) | Garment District / near Times Square, Madison Square Garden | 57 E 57th St — near Fifth Avenue and Central Park |
| Size (rooms) | 489 rooms | 368 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Family / age policy | All ages welcome; check-in minimum 21 | Family friendly; not adults-only |
| Pools | No pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Altair (main), Bar Room at Altair, Café at Altair, seasonal ART Midtown rooftop | 1 restaurant and 1 bar/lounge listed (The Garden Restaurant and bar/lounge in supplier highlights) |
| Spa / wellness | 24-hour fitness/wellness studio, rooftop yoga programming | Not published |
| Event & meeting space | 3,026 sq ft total; rooftop and multiple small studios; up to ~150 guests | Conference center and meeting rooms; 12,120 sq ft (1,126 m²) of conference space |
| Signature features | Seasonal rooftop bar ART Midtown, Urban Fee with included perks | Central Park and Fifth Avenue proximity; down comforters and deep soaking tubs |
| Accessibility & services | 24-hour front desk, concierge, multilingual staff, pet friendly | 24-hour front desk, limo/town car service available, concierge, valet (surcharge) |
Location: Arlo Midtown vs Four Seasons Hotel New York
Arlo Midtown – Location
Arlo Midtown sits at 351 West 38th Street in the Garment District, within easy walking distance of Penn Station, Madison Square Garden and Times Square.
- About a 6–10 minute walk to Times Square and Madison Square Garden.
- Closely linked to Javits Center and Port Authority transit connections.
- No on-site airport shuttle; nearest subway stations include 42nd St–Port Authority and 34th St–Penn Station.
Arlo is very central for event-goers and theater traffic in mid/West Midtown.
Four Seasons Hotel New York – Location
Four Seasons Hotel New York is at 57 E 57th Street, closer to Fifth Avenue and the southeast corner of Central Park.
- A short walk to Fifth Avenue shopping and the south edge of Central Park.
- Listed distances put Central Park and Rockefeller Center within a few blocks.
- Preferred airport listed as LaGuardia (LGA); limo/town car service available.
Four Seasons is better positioned for visitors prioritizing Central Park, Fifth Avenue and Midtown East attractions.
Rooms: compact & modern vs larger, decorated rooms
Arlo Midtown – Rooms
Arlo Midtown offers compact, modern rooms and suites with a focus on practical amenities and included Urban Fee perks.
- Nine room types including Room, Terrace, City View and Suite (Arlo).
- Urban Fee covers in-room high-speed Wi‑Fi, two daily cans of water, Citi Bike passes and fitness content.
- Rooms designed around efficiency; check-in minimum age 21 and family-friendly policies apply.
Choose Arlo for modern, efficiently designed rooms and bundled in‑stay perks via the Urban Fee.
Four Seasons Hotel New York – Rooms
Four Seasons lists individually decorated guestrooms and a range of Junior Suites and larger suites including Central Park Suite and Manhattan Suite options.
- Room types include Junior Suite City View King, Central Park Suite King, Manhattan Suite and multi-bedroom suites.
- Rooms described with down comforters, premium bedding and deep soaking bathtubs.
- Complimentary wireless internet access noted; some services/amenities carry surcharges.
Four Seasons suits guests wanting larger, traditionally furnished rooms and multi-room suite options.
Dining & drinks: neighborhood-focused dining vs formal hotel dining
Arlo Midtown – Dining & drinks
Arlo Midtown centers dining around Altair and several casual outlets plus a seasonal rooftop bar.
- Altair offers modern‑American menus for breakfast, lunch, dinner and weekend brunch.
- Bar Room at Altair and Café at Altair cover casual drinks and coffee/pastries.
- ART Midtown rooftop is seasonal and used for sunset drinks and private events (currently noted closed until a future rooftop season).
Arlo offers casual-to-polished on-site dining with strong rooftop/event options when seasonal rooftop is open.
Four Seasons Hotel New York – Dining & drinks
Supplier highlights list The Garden Restaurant and a bar/lounge; 24‑hour room service is available.
- Cooked‑to‑order breakfasts available for a surcharge; one on-site restaurant and a bar/lounge are noted.
- 24‑hour room service and formal dining options align with five‑star expectations.
- Concierge and in‑house staff can help with reservations and special requests; some meal items may carry extra fees.
Four Seasons focuses on classic hotel dining with room service and formal restaurant offerings; some items are surchargeable.
Pools & signature amenity: rooftop events vs conference and room comfort
Arlo Midtown – Pools & signature amenity
Arlo Midtown’s standout non-room features are event spaces and a seasonal rooftop bar rather than a swimming pool.
- No on-site swimming pool; 24‑hour fitness center and wellness programming instead.
- Rooftop ART Midtown hosts private events for up to 90 guests when in season.
- Multiple small and mid-sized event rooms support meetings and social gatherings.
Arlo is about rooftop events, meeting flexibility and fitness, not poolside leisure.
Four Seasons Hotel New York – Pools & signature amenity
Four Seasons presents larger conference space and room comforts as core selling points.
- Conference center and meeting rooms totaling about 12,120 sq ft (1,126 m²).
- Rooms highlighted for premium bedding and deep soaking tubs.
- Limo/town car and valet services handle upscale arrival and departure logistics (surcharges may apply).
Four Seasons leans on suite comfort and large meeting/conference facilities rather than rooftop social programming.
Wellness & nightlife: fitness access vs full-service luxury support
Arlo Midtown – Wellness & nightlife
Arlo Midtown emphasizes 24/7 fitness, wellness programming and a lively bar program.
- 24‑hour fitness studio with Peloton bikes, TRX and a stretching room; Alo Moves content included via Urban Fee.
- Seasonal rooftop yoga and guided meditation when programming is scheduled.
- On-site bars and a rooftop create evening social options without leaving the hotel.
Pick Arlo if round-the-clock fitness and an on-site nightlife vibe matter.
Four Seasons Hotel New York – Wellness & nightlife
Four Seasons provides concierge-led luxury services and traditional hotel amenities for relaxation and business needs.
- Multilingual staff, concierge, babysitting/childcare (surcharge) and business center support.
- Valet parking and limo/town car service (surcharges) help travelers with arrivals/departures.
- Supplier listing references fitness facilities; specific spa/pool details are not published in the supplied listing.
Four Seasons is built for guests who prioritize polished service and full-service hotel support.
Who Wins? Best Pick by Travel Style
Arlo Midtown
Arlo Midtown — seasonal ART Midtown rooftop and multiple flexible event rooms make it easier to host lively Midtown gatherings.
Four Seasons Hotel New York
Four Seasons Hotel New York — a high-profile five-star address with individually decorated rooms and larger suite options.
Arlo Midtown
Arlo Midtown — 24-hour fitness studio, Peloton bikes and Urban Fee benefits like in-room high-speed Wi‑Fi and Alo Moves.
Four Seasons Hotel New York
Four Seasons Hotel New York — extensive conference space (about 12,120 sq ft / 1,126 m²) and ballroom facilities.
Frequently asked questions
See all FAQs →Arlo Midtown vs Four Seasons Hotel New York: FAQs
Which hotel is better for a rooftop drink with skyline views?
Arlo Midtown — ART Midtown rooftop bar (seasonal) is the place for skyline cocktails; note the rooftop operates spring–fall and may be closed between seasons.
Which hotel is better for large corporate conferences?
Four Seasons Hotel New York offers a larger total conference footprint (about 12,120 sq ft) and ballroom space; Arlo Midtown is a strong choice for smaller or more casual events and rooftop receptions.
Do either hotel have a swimming pool?
Arlo Midtown does not have a swimming pool. For Four Seasons Hotel New York, the supplied listing does not publish pool details.
Are these hotels family friendly?
Yes. Arlo Midtown welcomes children of all ages (check-in minimum 21). Four Seasons Hotel New York is listed as family friendly in supplier highlights and is not adults-only.
More Arlo Midtown Comparison Guides
Explore how Arlo Midtown stacks up against other hotels nearby:
- Arlo Midtown vs Waldorf Astoria New York
- Arlo Midtown vs The St. Regis New York
- Arlo Midtown vs The Ritz-Carlton New York, Central Park
- Arlo Midtown vs Mandarin Oriental, New York
- Arlo Midtown vs Park Hyatt New York
- Arlo Midtown vs Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York
- Arlo Midtown vs The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel
- Arlo Midtown vs The Pierre, A Taj Hotel, New York
- Arlo Midtown vs JW Marriott Essex House New York
- Arlo Midtown vs Lotte New York Palace
- Arlo Midtown vs The Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad
- Arlo Midtown vs New York Marriott Marquis
- Arlo Midtown vs The New York EDITION
- Arlo Midtown vs The Times Square EDITION
- Arlo Midtown vs The Langham, New York, Fifth Avenue
- Arlo Midtown vs 1 Hotel Central Park
- Arlo Midtown vs The Dominick
- Arlo Midtown vs The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel
- All Arlo Midtown comparisons
Book your stay
Urban Fee: Wi‑Fi, Citi Bike & More
- Lowest rate guarantee
- Complimentary perks & upgrades
- 24/7 concierge